The short answer: pick by protein, not by packaging
Thrive Tuna Treats and Thrive Salmon Treats are both single-protein, freeze-dried fish treats for cats, so the real decision comes down to which fish your cat prefers and how much you want in each tube. The tuna version comes in a 25g tube; the salmon version comes in a 20g tube. Both are positioned as pure fish with no added sugar, additives or preservatives, and both are described as suitable for cats of all ages.
If your cat already loves tuna, the 25g tuna tube gives you slightly more treats per pack. If salmon is the favourite, the 20g salmon tube is the direct match. Neither product is supplied with feeding amounts or a daily treat limit, so use them as a reward rather than a meal replacement and treat the pack size as a convenience, not a portion guide.
Tuna vs salmon at a glance
- Main protein: Tuna Treats are described as 100% tuna. Salmon Treats are described as 100% real salmon pieces.
- Pack size: Tuna comes in a 25g tube (also available as 6 x 25g and 12 x 25g). Salmon comes in a 20g tube (also available as 6 x 20g).
- Price per gram at catalog prices: Tuna at USD 2.20 for 25g works out to about USD 0.088 per gram. Salmon at USD 2.51 for 20g works out to about USD 0.126 per gram. The tuna tube is the lower-cost option per gram in the supplied catalog.
- Freeze-dried: Both products are freeze-dried to lock in flavour. The tuna record also says the process preserves nutrients while intensifying taste.
- Additives and sugar: Both records state no additives or preservatives and no added sugar.
- Age suitability: The tuna record says perfect for cats of all ages; the salmon record says perfect for cats of all ages.
What the tuna record confirms
- Thrive Tuna Treats for Cats 25g: Made with sustainable Atlantic tuna caught using the dolphin-friendly pole and line method. If sourcing method matters to you, this is the one clear ethical claim in the supplied records.

Thrive Tuna Treats for Cats 25g - Thrive Tuna Treats for Cats 25g: 100% tuna, with no additives, preservatives or added sugar. A single-ingredient treat is easier to fit into a cat's diet when you want to avoid extra flavourings or sugar.
- Thrive Tuna Treats for Cats 25g: Freeze-dried to lock in flavour, in a handy re-sealable tube. The re-sealable tube helps keep the treats crisp between servings, especially if you buy the 25g size.
What the salmon record confirms
- Thrive Salmon Treats for Cats 20g: Made with 100% real salmon pieces and nothing else. A pure salmon treat is a straightforward alternative for cats that turn their nose up at tuna.

Thrive Salmon Treats for Cats 20g - Thrive Salmon Treats for Cats 20g: No derivatives, no sugar, no additives and no preservatives. Matches the tuna's clean-label positioning, so the choice is really about fish type and pack size.
- Thrive Salmon Treats for Cats 20g: Freeze-dried to preserve maximum flavour and nutrition. Freeze-drying keeps the treats shelf-stable and light, which is useful for training or travel.
Where the two treats genuinely differ
The protein source is the obvious split: tuna versus salmon. Beyond that, the supplied records are very similar. Both are single-fish, freeze-dried treats with no added sugar or additives, and both are described as suitable for cats of all ages. The tuna record adds a specific sourcing claim (sustainable Atlantic tuna, pole and line), while the salmon record does not include a comparable sourcing statement in the supplied information. That is a difference in what is documented, not proof that the salmon is sourced differently.
Pack size is the other practical difference. The tuna tube holds 25g; the salmon tube holds 20g. If you are buying for a multi-cat household or want a longer-lasting tube, the tuna's larger single tube and its 6 x 25g and 12 x 20g-style multi-packs give you more options. The salmon is available as a 20g tube or a 6 x 20g multi-pack. Neither record supplies a treat-per-day recommendation, so let your cat's overall diet and your vet's advice guide how often treats appear.
How to choose for your cat
- Start with what your cat already eats: If your cat reliably eats tuna-based wet food, the tuna treat is the lower-risk first tube. If salmon is the established favourite, start there.
- Compare cost per gram, not tube price: At catalog prices, the 25g tuna tube is cheaper per gram than the 20g salmon tube. If you are buying regularly, that gap adds up.
- Buy the smallest tube first: Both products are single-protein, but cats can be fussy. A 25g or 20g tube is a low-commitment way to test acceptance before buying a multi-pack.
- Use multi-packs for routine, not for a first trial: The 6 x 25g tuna pack and 6 x 20g salmon pack suit cats that already enjoy the flavour. They are not a shortcut around a taste test.
- Keep treats as a reward: Neither record gives a daily treat allowance. Treats should sit alongside a complete diet, not replace it.
What these records do not settle
The supplied information does not include a calorie count, a daily feeding amount, or a statement about whether these treats suit cats with specific dietary conditions. It also does not confirm texture beyond 'freeze-dried' or describe the size of individual pieces. If your cat has a diagnosed health issue or is on a prescription diet, ask your vet before adding any new treat, including a single-protein fish treat.
For most healthy cats, the decision is simple: choose the fish your cat enjoys, compare the tube size against how often you give treats, and use the per-gram price as a tie-breaker. The tuna tube is the better value per gram in the supplied catalog; the salmon tube is the direct swap if tuna is not a hit.



